PISTOL CARTRIDGES IN RIFLES FOR DEER HUNTING
I’m looking to start a “grass roots” campaign for the Michigan DNR to consider modifying the law concerning the use of Shotguns Only in the lower 1/3 of the State of Michigan, also known as Zone 3, to allow the use of straight walled pistol cartridges that are also used in rifles, and be able to hunt with those rifles.
Calibers used should be not less than .40 and not more than .50. This would include the .38-40 WCF (which is actually a .40 caliber bullet), .44-40, .45 Long Colt, .41 Magnum, .44 Magnum, .475 Linebaugh, up thru the .500 Smith & Wesson. Suitable rifles for these mainly old time cartridges would be the M73 Winchester, M66 Winchester, M92 Winchester, M94 Marlin etc. They are presently all available in reproduction form and mainly used in the Cowboy Action Shooting game. Sure would put meaning in “hunting” again. These cartridges, for the most part, are about as powerful as a shotgun with slugs and some will only carry a bit further than a shotgun slug. Basically, we’re talking about a good, solid 50 yard rifle with 100 yards being a pretty safe maximum. To avoid abuse of this proposed law, I also suggest rifle scopes be forbidden on these rifles for the purposes of hunting.
Cartridges such as the .56-50 Spencer, .45-70 Government, even though straight walled, are not normally “pistol cartridges” and would not be allowed in the Zone 3.
What got me to thinking about this was the new hunting regulations being implemented this year in Indiana, which has been a “shotgun only” State for many many, years. They are trying it out, Statewide, this year. I’m anxious to see if it’s going to work out down there. I received a call from the Michigan DNR today concerning another topic and at the end of the conversation I asked the agent about using the pistol caliber cartridges in rifles. He was intrigued by the question and asked me a lot of questions about it. Basically, “what-if’s”. When I mentioned that Indiana was implementing it this season he became quite alert. He did tell me that it would have to go thru several processes in order to even be considered but that he would definitely pass this proposal along to the powers that be.
Now, I realize that most of the active members of our forum live and hunt in Northern Michigan and this law would have no affect on them or their hunting. But for those other readers of the Blog and the forum who think this idea may have merit, I suggest calling the local DNR office and inquiring about the idea. Perhaps if enough of us do this we may be able to implement a change in the law. Sure would be a lot of fun to hunt with the old time rifles like our Grandfathers did, in the lower third of the State. The deer are here, the safety is here and the challenge is here. I think if enough of us call or write, something may happen.
Moose Hunting, 1968 C.L. Kamradt
Thursday, September 20th, 2007Posted in Butch's comments | No Comments »